A Reflection On Globalism and Community - Moral Philosophy Seminar

In February, the WHT scholars of 2020-21 participated in our fourth Moral Philosophy Seminar, on Globalism and Community. With a cohort drawing from 20 countries across four continents, now in a single city of learning, this was always going to be an interesting session. We prepared for the seminar by reading two famous reflections on globalisation - Martha Nussbaum's 'Patriotism and Cosmopolitanism' (1994) and David Goodhart's 'The Road to Somewhere' (2017). Though writing about different contexts, Nussbaum and Goodhart pose a similar question: as individuals, do our loyalties lie to the places we are born, or to the world? Are we "somewheres" rooted in the  communities of our birth, or "anywheres" dwelling in a global community of humans?

I realised through my own reflections and those voiced by other scholars, that Nussbaum and Goodhart were expressing a question that was in many of our minds. This question determines the political and social currents that shape the world we live in and the things we study; the accession of Donald Trump, Britain's exit from the European Union, the crises following refugees around the world. It also impacts our personal lives and choices: is our social responsibility to the places we are born, or to the places we choose? Do we all have an equal opportunity to choose between those modalities - or is that ability pre-determined by the places we call home, the languages we speak, and the colours of our skins?

Many scholars, myself included, felt that we were both rooted in our communities and open to the broader world - we questioned whether this dichotomy between "somewheres" and "anywheres" needed to exist. Yet we also realised that our ability to straddle these lines also stems from privilege - the privilege of being an international student in Oxford; the privilege of part of communities like the WHT; the privilege of feeling like the world is at our fingertips. Our conversation did not result in any concrete conclusions - perhaps the best discussions never do? - but, as with many moments in the WHT, it made me stop, think, and grow. I'm grateful to my fellow scholars, and to our fantastic facilitators Sarah, Paul and Siba, for this experience.